Types of Information Resources
Students need to be able to (outcomes)
- recognize various types of information resources and understand their value and differences
Students need to know (curriculum)
- advantages of using a variety of sources
- what the different information types are (Web/search engines, library databases, reference books,
popular magazines, scholarly journals)
- where to find each type of information
- how to use criteria for comparison (appropriateness, authority, currency, bias)
Learning activities (pedagogy)
- lecture about different types of information and why it's important to have a variety of tools
available (each tool is appropriate for a particular job)
- in-class exercise:
- students, working in groups, are given a research topic
- students compare and contrast two different types of information resource (subject encyclopedia
vs. Web, ProQuest vs. Google, Opposing Viewpoints database vs. Web, journal vs. magazine, two
different databases)
- each group must indicate strengths and weaknesses for each source
- each group reports their findings to the larger class
Assignment (assessment)
- students research a topic and are required to use at least five sources
- students create an annotated bibliography
- in the annotations, students reflect on these evaluation questions:
- who created the information?
- when was the information created?
- is the information biased?
- how did this source add to your knowledge of the topic?
Grading/Scoring (criteria)
- Annotated bibliography rubric (points assigned as appropriate):
- variety / appropriateness
- unacceptable - uses one type of information
- developing - uses a few types of information
- acceptable - uses many types of information that are somewhat appropriate to the topic
- proficient - uses many types of information that are all appropriate to the topic
- evaluation
- unacceptable - annotations do not discuss any of the evaluation questions
- developing - annotations discuss one or two of the evaluation questions
- acceptable - annotations discuss all four of the evaluation questions
- proficient - annotations discuss all four of the evaluation questions and demonstrate an
understanding of the value of each source